Chapter 6: Man in the Universe
1. The universe and the human being within it are no mere accidental happenings. It is part of the progressive relevation of the Unknowable to Its own limited forms caught within the boundaries of Its own Maya. This revelation is the real purpose of human life (and of all limited creation) too.
2. Since the descent of the Supreme into limited forms is a self-concealment with many layers, the enlightenment also naturally happens progressively, stage by stage, each unveiling bringing the seeker one more step closer to the One Supreme Reality.
3. Matter below conscious life also has a harmony and tranquility, but that harmony is more like a deep slumber, driven by a force which moves it but is not understood by it. In conscious life, where thoughts, emotions and impulses play a strong role, there seems to be more discord and disharmony than in the subliminal life below it. However, there is a harmony above conscious life (in the realm of the Superconscious) which man seeks and tries to guide his ordinary life by. The world of confusions and discords due to limited egoistical understanding is an intermediate level of development of consciousness between these two harmonious states.
4. In comtemplating on this higher harmony, though, man realizes the limits of conceptual knowledge in grasping this higher harmony. Sometimes, man thinks of a "beyond" which lies outside God, sometimes he thinks of ordinary life as being too cruel to be a manifestation of the same Supreme (or at least, he thinks of the Supreme as being concealed by something which is not the Supreme), etc. However, these experiences which seem to deny or oppose the concept of God and His Harmony are also real, even if temporary relative to the Supreme, and should be thought of as a result of a "wrong relation", says Sri Aurobindo, rather than as a complete illusion. The basis of these ordinary experiences is "wrong" in the same way that man thinking of the Sun as revolving around the Earth is. Viewed in this way, the discordant rhythms of egoistical existence can be understood as interim experiences on the way to the higher Harmony - and we do not need to think of them as mere "punishments of a fall".
5. Viewing error and discord as an interim step in the evolution of consciousness is helpful because let's keep in mind that man has little choice but to work with these experiences first! As even the Upanishads declare - man has to first transcend death through ignorance (avidyaa) before attaining to the Supreme Knowledge (vidyaa).
6. Such thinking can then be a foundation for the "practice of the divine life". To live the divine life, we will need to go into the depths of conscious experiences and identify ourselves with these higher states of understanding and knowledge - which is not natural to the untrained egoistical or sense mind. Merely living a superficial existence will not produce the needed experiences and hints which can help unravel the mystery of the soul and the concealed Universal Plan.
Chapter 7: The Ego and the Dualities
1. The dualities, sufferings, pains etc. of ordinary mortal consciousness are deeply reconciled into a higher Harmony only when the soul truly experiences itself as one with the Universal. There are indeed states of higher consciousness in which pain and pleasure merge into oneness and seem like different aspects of the same essential truth. Pain is merely the recoil of the limited adjunct (ego) to something it feels is harmful to itself - so it is another working of the same conscious force which is active when the limited being feels pleasure. Limiitations are nothing but the concealment of the Infinite by His own Maya.
2. Sri Aurobindo is not talking here of the possibilities in hypnotized states of the mind - something he brings up in a later chapter. That the mind is capable of so much more in hypnotized states should itself be proof of the mind's potential being much more than what comes out in ordinary experiences of untrained minds. However, here we are not concerned about the active powers of the mind to do things. Here, Sri Aurobindo states only that the Higher Understanding spoken of in so many places is truly possible to experience. With that Understanding and vision, it is possible to see the underlying unity even in the world of dualities.
3. For ordinary life, though, the evidence of the senses might still be given its due respect and place. To replace the ordinary understanding by a blind belief in the Higher, without truly understanding and realizing the Higher might cause more confusion and disruptions. Clearly, says Sri Aurobindo, this is why the Gita specifically asks people of knowledge to not "disturb" the life and thought-basis of the ignorant. The ignorant cannot just follow the example of the illumined without any real understanding.
4. The truth about whether the Sun revolves around the Earth or vice-versa could be made known to people through some means, but the knowledge will not be of much use to people unless a body of knowledge is created around the true relationship. Only then will the true knowedge matter - else, it would be a piece of information without much practical use. Similarly for the true relation between the individual ego and Universal Consciousness. We cannot expect people to give up the old ways of living unless the knowledge of the true relationship has some value to them at first. The Ape could not really have lived by the dream of using logical and reasoning faculties in the future. We are in a similar situation today - where we are being told that there is a potential in us which is much higher than what we perceive through the eyes of the limited ego and its ordinary logical and mental capacity. Unless we create a body of knowledge where this higher truth matters, we cannot expect people to start living by these higher principles.
5. In early Vedantic thought, the ego was thought of as a self-limitation of the universal consciousness - something which tied consciousness exclusively to limited forms and thereby led to the experience of dualities, pain and suffering. Later Vedantists, however, seem to have started thinking of the ego as an essential factor for the existence of the universe too. However, says Sri Aurobindo, it is important to understand that the realization of the Universal does not lead to an inevitable extinction of the egoistic personality. Of course, it would probably make egoistical distinctions much less important and petty at some level. The individual who "attains", he says, would be able to not only represent his limited self after realization, but would probably be benefitted because he would be able to see his limited existence in the correct light and in its actual relation to the universe around it.
Chapter 8: The Methods of Vedantic Knowledge
1. The way reason has two kinds of action - mixed and sovereign - so does the mind have two kinds of psychological experiences. Reason acts in its pure way when it takes the inputs from the senses, perhaps, but refuses to be limited by them and evaluates the inputs on its own by trying to arrive at more fundamental truths which are unalterable. Similarly, the mind experiences a mixed psychological action when it tries to become aware of the "external" world but when the same mind tries to become aware of itself, it experiences a pure or sovereign psychological action. In one action (or experience) the dependence on sense inputs is high. In the other, the awareness is more direct and not dependent on the senses.
2. The second kind of knowledge is "knowledge by identity" - it is said that we know (or we are aware of) anger because we become anger. Similarly, we are aware of our own existence because we become that. Sri Aurobindo says that in a way, all knowledge is knowledge by identity, but the mind is commonly trained to work only with the inputs of sense organs and with the division between subject and object, and it is due to this habit of the mind that we typically find ourselves caught up with partial and hazy views of reality, rather than the clear perception attainable through "knowledge by identity".
3. In states of hypnosis and some other similar psychological phenomena, this ability of the mind to work directly is seen at work, with sense organs being at most a starting point and with the confusing thoughts of the waking state being put away temporarily. The action is no longer "mixed and dependent" and therefore is a lot more powerful than the actions and experiences of the waking state. The extension of this faculty of the mind to the waking state is definitely not impossible, says Sri Aurobindo, but more difficult. Thus we see people who have advanced faculties of perception - like estimating the weight of objects accurately by simply holding them in their hands or the ability to perceive thoughts and feelings of other people correctly even if the data supplied by the senses (their expressions, etc.) is misleading.
4. Of course, these limited uses of the higher powers of the mind are not our real aim - our real aim is to attain oneness with that Universal One which is described in the Gita as "attainable to intelligence but transcending the senses". The way this "knowledge by identity" reveals detailed and correct information when applied to limited objects, it is expected that by applying the mind directly to the Universal, that Supreme truth will be known to the seeker, including various details as relevant. Indian Vendanta bases itself upon this view. By knowing the Self deeply, as not only the inner Self within the body but also as the Universal Self extending outside the body, the Universal can therefore be made known, by the process of knowledge by identity.
5. Reason (as ordinarily understood) is a mediator between the subconscient (from where man comes) to the superconscient (towards which man is progressing). The subconscient and superconscient are two different formulations of the same One. In the subconscient, knowledge is involved in action, whereas in the superconscient, action itself is contained within a supreme consciousness. Therefore, the "master-words" of the subconscient and superconscient are, respectively, Life and Light. Intuition is common to the two states, but in one, intuition is expressed mainly in action, whereas in the other, intuition manifests in its true nature as knowledge by identity. Reason is an intermediary between these states, and in the superconscient, it converts itself into the fully illumined knowledge by identity. In fact, it is because the sages of Ancient India recognized illumined intuition as arising from knowledge by identity that they placed it above reason, and came up with a tradition where while ordinary reason would be used to explain and justify the truths "seen" by the great ones, the Truths "seen" or intuited by the greats would be considered superior to ordinary reason. Later on, of course, reason started acquiring a greater and greater place within the philosophical traditions, and thus we saw the development of many schools of thought - all supposedly based on the Vedas, but often using reason merely to attack each other's interpretations. These discussions therefore started moving away from the central tenets of the scriptures, which were Revelations of truths not always easy to describe in words but placed above ordinary logic just for that reason by the sages. Of course, from time to time, says Sri Aurobindo, there have also been efforts to revive the true teachings of the scriptures and to synthetize them in a way such that the knowledge would come across as a wholistic view, wherein various contradictions introduced by ordinary logic would be resolved.
6. The use of reason - replacing the acceptance of higher intuition by ordinary reason - is not without its merits, because it is only by this kind of a process that the "lower faculties" are compelled to assimilate and understand whatever they can of the higher truths and to organize and align themselves better to the higher vision. The lower faculties can thereby enrich themselves, and re-organize themselves to be better vehicles of the higher, resulting in a more complete harmony. Without this process, many parts of our personality would remain depressed or undeveloped. The balance is set right by this process of compelling the lower nature to understand and accomodate the higher truths. While the ancient Vedantic rishis perhaps worked mainly out of their intuition of the higher truths, and while we are justified in calling for a re-establishment of their intuition as a knowledge placed above ordinary reason, this seeming "descent" of Indian thought into a a body of knowledge dominated by ordinary reason is also not really a descent, but rather another opportunity to create a more complete and integral basis for the higher truths within the lower faculties of egoistic intelligence.
Chapter 9: The Pure Existent
1. Man initially tends to think of Universal consciousness as centered around himself but when careful reflection makes clear that the Cosmic Intelligence has a dynamic of its own and exists not just for the limited entity he represents, man tends to underestimate the importance of the individual unduly. Both extremes are incorrect - neither does Supreme and His creation revolve around the individual ego nor is the egoistical being unimportant to Him. In fact, It (Brahman) gives itself equally to all its creation - although each created form differs fom others in quality or quantity (size). Sri Aurobindo says that the force of strength that goes into making a strong man is no more or less than the force of weakness that goes into making a weak man! The energy spent in repression is as great as that spent in expression, and looking at it this way, it is easier to understand that Brahman is "equally" present everywhere, despite seeming differences.
2. To understand the relationship of the individual to the universal - and not go to both extremes - it would help to understand better what this Universal is. If it is an energy present everywhere, then is it forever in motion, or is the Supreme even beyond manifest energy, and therefore described in the Gita as the "sthaanu"? In normal consciousness, rest and motion are easy to ascribe to the same object, but upon closer inspection, it seems that what seems to be at rest in our usual world is yet another force in motion, only that our senses fail to see the underlying motion. If so, then is this Universal only eternal movement with absolutely no rest (in other words, is it only Shakti with no Shiva)? Sri Aurobindo feels that this hypothesis leaves the staircase of ascent without any support and contradicts reason - it gives us a feeling that this could not be the truth.
3. Intuition suggests, and Sri Aurobindo says, that this "Pure Existent" beyond the eternal movement is no mere theory - it is the fundamental reality. On the other hand, neither is it true to say that the movement seen everywhere is a mere illusion and Brahman is only the "Pure Existent" in a position of rest with no possibility of motion. Both the "being" and the "becoming" are truths - neither is a mere illusion or mental concept. In ordinary life, we think in terms of stability and rest. Both of these are aspects of our Supreme Reality, and what's more, so is the "silent Brahman" described in earlier chapters, which sustains and permits all manifestation (in rest or in motion).
4. So both "Shiva" and "Shakti" are to be thought of as truths and not mere illusions or concepts. However, says Sri Aurobindo, what is very important is to understand the nature of this Shakti. Is it merely a force without any intelligence? Is intelligence just one phenomenal result of force, or is it rather its secret and true nature? Or, to use the Vedantic terms, is Prakriti really a power of "Chit" - the creative Self-Conscious force? On this, says Sri Aurobindo, all the rest hinges.
Chapter 10: Conscious Force
1. On the question of how Universal Force came to manifest into varied forms, the ancient Indian answer is that the five basic elements were created, because with only one or a few of these, stable and separate individual forms could not be maintained. The manifestation started with Vibration (sound, or the Word, or Aum or Amen) and the last in the sequence was the Earth element - the element which represents the power of cohesiveness, required for solids to stay in form. All matter is said to be a composite of these five basic constituents. Yet, this did not adequately explain how these forms perceived each other and were endowed with individual consciousness, so the seers of the Sankhya (analytical) tradition explained it by way of inactive conscious souls in which the activities of material nature are reflected, thus giving the world of matter the power of consciousness too.
2. From the rational perspective, this explanation made sense, because the ordinary observer observes both consciousness as well as varied movements of material forces in his world. However, once the existence of a Pure Existence is accepted (as we did in the last chapter), the natural question arises as to what caused the Force to move (or who willed the Force to move) and why, in the first place? The Indian tradition answered the "what" part of the question by suggesting that the silent and the active Brahman are actuall one and not two separate existences. Force is inherent (even if sleeping) in Existence and it is no mystery that it arises from the silent Existence at times. The next question is "why" and it is clear that the question does not arise if we assume that consciousness is only a by-product of the moving, unintelligent Force. However, is that indeed so - is consciouness merely a by-product of otherwise unintelligent forces?
3. Increasingly, new knowledge is bringing to light powers of the mind way beyond the sense organs and the nervous system including the physical brain. There are remote but clear pointers to the fact that even the heartbeat and the so-called critical functions are not truly indispensable in all cases. Therefore, the orthodox position that consciousness is a by-product of the nervous system, the brain and its instruments is fast becoming indefensible. Sri Aurobindo says that the way the power of steam existed prior to the development of the steam engine, consciousness existed prior to the development of the brain and the nervous system.
4. So has this force of consciousness come from outside and possessed matter, so to speak, perhaps with some partial loss of its own sovereignty? Not really, says Sri Aurobindo. Consciousness is integrally intertwined with matter and in the Shakti of Shiva. In fact, the proof of some subliminal consciousness being present not only in plants but also in inert metals goes to support the idea that consciousness is not something which came from the outside to possess matter. The ancient thinkers did believe in other worlds and other dimensions where consciousness exists, but these worlds are not created by the entry of an external conscious force. Consciousness is, rather, all-pervading and exists both below and above ordinary human mentality (in subconscious and superconscious states). If the objection is that consciousness implies some kind of design, and therefore could not be the original Mother Force, Sri Aurobindo says that a design (even if with some evident discord and disharmony on the surface) is quite evident in creation anyway and so this fact too, favors the idea of the existence of a Universal Conscious Force. Finally, once we accept that the Pure Existence had the power of consciousness, then the problem of why it moved can be answered too. As Sri Aurobindo explains in a different chapter, the universe is merely one of Its infinite possibilities worked out in action, with self-concealment being the beginning of this particular Divine Play. The force evolves all these forms, but it is essentially still the one Universal force. The same consciousness which in sub-conscious life seems to be involed within matter, emerges as a distinct force in mental (human) activity and will evolve into its higher and purer forms as we keep going to states above ordinary human mentality.
5. The Force (Shakti) that builds the universe is very much a conscious force. It has manifested increasingly superior forms which sustain increasingly higher levels of consciousness (from the subliminal metal consciousness to the human), and it seems evident that the goal is to reach Its Perfect Potential within forms too.
Sadanand Tutakne
1. The universe and the human being within it are no mere accidental happenings. It is part of the progressive relevation of the Unknowable to Its own limited forms caught within the boundaries of Its own Maya. This revelation is the real purpose of human life (and of all limited creation) too.
2. Since the descent of the Supreme into limited forms is a self-concealment with many layers, the enlightenment also naturally happens progressively, stage by stage, each unveiling bringing the seeker one more step closer to the One Supreme Reality.
3. Matter below conscious life also has a harmony and tranquility, but that harmony is more like a deep slumber, driven by a force which moves it but is not understood by it. In conscious life, where thoughts, emotions and impulses play a strong role, there seems to be more discord and disharmony than in the subliminal life below it. However, there is a harmony above conscious life (in the realm of the Superconscious) which man seeks and tries to guide his ordinary life by. The world of confusions and discords due to limited egoistical understanding is an intermediate level of development of consciousness between these two harmonious states.
4. In comtemplating on this higher harmony, though, man realizes the limits of conceptual knowledge in grasping this higher harmony. Sometimes, man thinks of a "beyond" which lies outside God, sometimes he thinks of ordinary life as being too cruel to be a manifestation of the same Supreme (or at least, he thinks of the Supreme as being concealed by something which is not the Supreme), etc. However, these experiences which seem to deny or oppose the concept of God and His Harmony are also real, even if temporary relative to the Supreme, and should be thought of as a result of a "wrong relation", says Sri Aurobindo, rather than as a complete illusion. The basis of these ordinary experiences is "wrong" in the same way that man thinking of the Sun as revolving around the Earth is. Viewed in this way, the discordant rhythms of egoistical existence can be understood as interim experiences on the way to the higher Harmony - and we do not need to think of them as mere "punishments of a fall".
5. Viewing error and discord as an interim step in the evolution of consciousness is helpful because let's keep in mind that man has little choice but to work with these experiences first! As even the Upanishads declare - man has to first transcend death through ignorance (avidyaa) before attaining to the Supreme Knowledge (vidyaa).
6. Such thinking can then be a foundation for the "practice of the divine life". To live the divine life, we will need to go into the depths of conscious experiences and identify ourselves with these higher states of understanding and knowledge - which is not natural to the untrained egoistical or sense mind. Merely living a superficial existence will not produce the needed experiences and hints which can help unravel the mystery of the soul and the concealed Universal Plan.
Chapter 7: The Ego and the Dualities
1. The dualities, sufferings, pains etc. of ordinary mortal consciousness are deeply reconciled into a higher Harmony only when the soul truly experiences itself as one with the Universal. There are indeed states of higher consciousness in which pain and pleasure merge into oneness and seem like different aspects of the same essential truth. Pain is merely the recoil of the limited adjunct (ego) to something it feels is harmful to itself - so it is another working of the same conscious force which is active when the limited being feels pleasure. Limiitations are nothing but the concealment of the Infinite by His own Maya.
2. Sri Aurobindo is not talking here of the possibilities in hypnotized states of the mind - something he brings up in a later chapter. That the mind is capable of so much more in hypnotized states should itself be proof of the mind's potential being much more than what comes out in ordinary experiences of untrained minds. However, here we are not concerned about the active powers of the mind to do things. Here, Sri Aurobindo states only that the Higher Understanding spoken of in so many places is truly possible to experience. With that Understanding and vision, it is possible to see the underlying unity even in the world of dualities.
3. For ordinary life, though, the evidence of the senses might still be given its due respect and place. To replace the ordinary understanding by a blind belief in the Higher, without truly understanding and realizing the Higher might cause more confusion and disruptions. Clearly, says Sri Aurobindo, this is why the Gita specifically asks people of knowledge to not "disturb" the life and thought-basis of the ignorant. The ignorant cannot just follow the example of the illumined without any real understanding.
4. The truth about whether the Sun revolves around the Earth or vice-versa could be made known to people through some means, but the knowledge will not be of much use to people unless a body of knowledge is created around the true relationship. Only then will the true knowedge matter - else, it would be a piece of information without much practical use. Similarly for the true relation between the individual ego and Universal Consciousness. We cannot expect people to give up the old ways of living unless the knowledge of the true relationship has some value to them at first. The Ape could not really have lived by the dream of using logical and reasoning faculties in the future. We are in a similar situation today - where we are being told that there is a potential in us which is much higher than what we perceive through the eyes of the limited ego and its ordinary logical and mental capacity. Unless we create a body of knowledge where this higher truth matters, we cannot expect people to start living by these higher principles.
5. In early Vedantic thought, the ego was thought of as a self-limitation of the universal consciousness - something which tied consciousness exclusively to limited forms and thereby led to the experience of dualities, pain and suffering. Later Vedantists, however, seem to have started thinking of the ego as an essential factor for the existence of the universe too. However, says Sri Aurobindo, it is important to understand that the realization of the Universal does not lead to an inevitable extinction of the egoistic personality. Of course, it would probably make egoistical distinctions much less important and petty at some level. The individual who "attains", he says, would be able to not only represent his limited self after realization, but would probably be benefitted because he would be able to see his limited existence in the correct light and in its actual relation to the universe around it.
Chapter 8: The Methods of Vedantic Knowledge
1. The way reason has two kinds of action - mixed and sovereign - so does the mind have two kinds of psychological experiences. Reason acts in its pure way when it takes the inputs from the senses, perhaps, but refuses to be limited by them and evaluates the inputs on its own by trying to arrive at more fundamental truths which are unalterable. Similarly, the mind experiences a mixed psychological action when it tries to become aware of the "external" world but when the same mind tries to become aware of itself, it experiences a pure or sovereign psychological action. In one action (or experience) the dependence on sense inputs is high. In the other, the awareness is more direct and not dependent on the senses.
2. The second kind of knowledge is "knowledge by identity" - it is said that we know (or we are aware of) anger because we become anger. Similarly, we are aware of our own existence because we become that. Sri Aurobindo says that in a way, all knowledge is knowledge by identity, but the mind is commonly trained to work only with the inputs of sense organs and with the division between subject and object, and it is due to this habit of the mind that we typically find ourselves caught up with partial and hazy views of reality, rather than the clear perception attainable through "knowledge by identity".
3. In states of hypnosis and some other similar psychological phenomena, this ability of the mind to work directly is seen at work, with sense organs being at most a starting point and with the confusing thoughts of the waking state being put away temporarily. The action is no longer "mixed and dependent" and therefore is a lot more powerful than the actions and experiences of the waking state. The extension of this faculty of the mind to the waking state is definitely not impossible, says Sri Aurobindo, but more difficult. Thus we see people who have advanced faculties of perception - like estimating the weight of objects accurately by simply holding them in their hands or the ability to perceive thoughts and feelings of other people correctly even if the data supplied by the senses (their expressions, etc.) is misleading.
4. Of course, these limited uses of the higher powers of the mind are not our real aim - our real aim is to attain oneness with that Universal One which is described in the Gita as "attainable to intelligence but transcending the senses". The way this "knowledge by identity" reveals detailed and correct information when applied to limited objects, it is expected that by applying the mind directly to the Universal, that Supreme truth will be known to the seeker, including various details as relevant. Indian Vendanta bases itself upon this view. By knowing the Self deeply, as not only the inner Self within the body but also as the Universal Self extending outside the body, the Universal can therefore be made known, by the process of knowledge by identity.
5. Reason (as ordinarily understood) is a mediator between the subconscient (from where man comes) to the superconscient (towards which man is progressing). The subconscient and superconscient are two different formulations of the same One. In the subconscient, knowledge is involved in action, whereas in the superconscient, action itself is contained within a supreme consciousness. Therefore, the "master-words" of the subconscient and superconscient are, respectively, Life and Light. Intuition is common to the two states, but in one, intuition is expressed mainly in action, whereas in the other, intuition manifests in its true nature as knowledge by identity. Reason is an intermediary between these states, and in the superconscient, it converts itself into the fully illumined knowledge by identity. In fact, it is because the sages of Ancient India recognized illumined intuition as arising from knowledge by identity that they placed it above reason, and came up with a tradition where while ordinary reason would be used to explain and justify the truths "seen" by the great ones, the Truths "seen" or intuited by the greats would be considered superior to ordinary reason. Later on, of course, reason started acquiring a greater and greater place within the philosophical traditions, and thus we saw the development of many schools of thought - all supposedly based on the Vedas, but often using reason merely to attack each other's interpretations. These discussions therefore started moving away from the central tenets of the scriptures, which were Revelations of truths not always easy to describe in words but placed above ordinary logic just for that reason by the sages. Of course, from time to time, says Sri Aurobindo, there have also been efforts to revive the true teachings of the scriptures and to synthetize them in a way such that the knowledge would come across as a wholistic view, wherein various contradictions introduced by ordinary logic would be resolved.
6. The use of reason - replacing the acceptance of higher intuition by ordinary reason - is not without its merits, because it is only by this kind of a process that the "lower faculties" are compelled to assimilate and understand whatever they can of the higher truths and to organize and align themselves better to the higher vision. The lower faculties can thereby enrich themselves, and re-organize themselves to be better vehicles of the higher, resulting in a more complete harmony. Without this process, many parts of our personality would remain depressed or undeveloped. The balance is set right by this process of compelling the lower nature to understand and accomodate the higher truths. While the ancient Vedantic rishis perhaps worked mainly out of their intuition of the higher truths, and while we are justified in calling for a re-establishment of their intuition as a knowledge placed above ordinary reason, this seeming "descent" of Indian thought into a a body of knowledge dominated by ordinary reason is also not really a descent, but rather another opportunity to create a more complete and integral basis for the higher truths within the lower faculties of egoistic intelligence.
Chapter 9: The Pure Existent
1. Man initially tends to think of Universal consciousness as centered around himself but when careful reflection makes clear that the Cosmic Intelligence has a dynamic of its own and exists not just for the limited entity he represents, man tends to underestimate the importance of the individual unduly. Both extremes are incorrect - neither does Supreme and His creation revolve around the individual ego nor is the egoistical being unimportant to Him. In fact, It (Brahman) gives itself equally to all its creation - although each created form differs fom others in quality or quantity (size). Sri Aurobindo says that the force of strength that goes into making a strong man is no more or less than the force of weakness that goes into making a weak man! The energy spent in repression is as great as that spent in expression, and looking at it this way, it is easier to understand that Brahman is "equally" present everywhere, despite seeming differences.
2. To understand the relationship of the individual to the universal - and not go to both extremes - it would help to understand better what this Universal is. If it is an energy present everywhere, then is it forever in motion, or is the Supreme even beyond manifest energy, and therefore described in the Gita as the "sthaanu"? In normal consciousness, rest and motion are easy to ascribe to the same object, but upon closer inspection, it seems that what seems to be at rest in our usual world is yet another force in motion, only that our senses fail to see the underlying motion. If so, then is this Universal only eternal movement with absolutely no rest (in other words, is it only Shakti with no Shiva)? Sri Aurobindo feels that this hypothesis leaves the staircase of ascent without any support and contradicts reason - it gives us a feeling that this could not be the truth.
3. Intuition suggests, and Sri Aurobindo says, that this "Pure Existent" beyond the eternal movement is no mere theory - it is the fundamental reality. On the other hand, neither is it true to say that the movement seen everywhere is a mere illusion and Brahman is only the "Pure Existent" in a position of rest with no possibility of motion. Both the "being" and the "becoming" are truths - neither is a mere illusion or mental concept. In ordinary life, we think in terms of stability and rest. Both of these are aspects of our Supreme Reality, and what's more, so is the "silent Brahman" described in earlier chapters, which sustains and permits all manifestation (in rest or in motion).
4. So both "Shiva" and "Shakti" are to be thought of as truths and not mere illusions or concepts. However, says Sri Aurobindo, what is very important is to understand the nature of this Shakti. Is it merely a force without any intelligence? Is intelligence just one phenomenal result of force, or is it rather its secret and true nature? Or, to use the Vedantic terms, is Prakriti really a power of "Chit" - the creative Self-Conscious force? On this, says Sri Aurobindo, all the rest hinges.
Chapter 10: Conscious Force
1. On the question of how Universal Force came to manifest into varied forms, the ancient Indian answer is that the five basic elements were created, because with only one or a few of these, stable and separate individual forms could not be maintained. The manifestation started with Vibration (sound, or the Word, or Aum or Amen) and the last in the sequence was the Earth element - the element which represents the power of cohesiveness, required for solids to stay in form. All matter is said to be a composite of these five basic constituents. Yet, this did not adequately explain how these forms perceived each other and were endowed with individual consciousness, so the seers of the Sankhya (analytical) tradition explained it by way of inactive conscious souls in which the activities of material nature are reflected, thus giving the world of matter the power of consciousness too.
2. From the rational perspective, this explanation made sense, because the ordinary observer observes both consciousness as well as varied movements of material forces in his world. However, once the existence of a Pure Existence is accepted (as we did in the last chapter), the natural question arises as to what caused the Force to move (or who willed the Force to move) and why, in the first place? The Indian tradition answered the "what" part of the question by suggesting that the silent and the active Brahman are actuall one and not two separate existences. Force is inherent (even if sleeping) in Existence and it is no mystery that it arises from the silent Existence at times. The next question is "why" and it is clear that the question does not arise if we assume that consciousness is only a by-product of the moving, unintelligent Force. However, is that indeed so - is consciouness merely a by-product of otherwise unintelligent forces?
3. Increasingly, new knowledge is bringing to light powers of the mind way beyond the sense organs and the nervous system including the physical brain. There are remote but clear pointers to the fact that even the heartbeat and the so-called critical functions are not truly indispensable in all cases. Therefore, the orthodox position that consciousness is a by-product of the nervous system, the brain and its instruments is fast becoming indefensible. Sri Aurobindo says that the way the power of steam existed prior to the development of the steam engine, consciousness existed prior to the development of the brain and the nervous system.
4. So has this force of consciousness come from outside and possessed matter, so to speak, perhaps with some partial loss of its own sovereignty? Not really, says Sri Aurobindo. Consciousness is integrally intertwined with matter and in the Shakti of Shiva. In fact, the proof of some subliminal consciousness being present not only in plants but also in inert metals goes to support the idea that consciousness is not something which came from the outside to possess matter. The ancient thinkers did believe in other worlds and other dimensions where consciousness exists, but these worlds are not created by the entry of an external conscious force. Consciousness is, rather, all-pervading and exists both below and above ordinary human mentality (in subconscious and superconscious states). If the objection is that consciousness implies some kind of design, and therefore could not be the original Mother Force, Sri Aurobindo says that a design (even if with some evident discord and disharmony on the surface) is quite evident in creation anyway and so this fact too, favors the idea of the existence of a Universal Conscious Force. Finally, once we accept that the Pure Existence had the power of consciousness, then the problem of why it moved can be answered too. As Sri Aurobindo explains in a different chapter, the universe is merely one of Its infinite possibilities worked out in action, with self-concealment being the beginning of this particular Divine Play. The force evolves all these forms, but it is essentially still the one Universal force. The same consciousness which in sub-conscious life seems to be involed within matter, emerges as a distinct force in mental (human) activity and will evolve into its higher and purer forms as we keep going to states above ordinary human mentality.
5. The Force (Shakti) that builds the universe is very much a conscious force. It has manifested increasingly superior forms which sustain increasingly higher levels of consciousness (from the subliminal metal consciousness to the human), and it seems evident that the goal is to reach Its Perfect Potential within forms too.
Sadanand Tutakne